Hi @ZGamm ,
First of all, a big thank you to @zber2 for the troubleshooting here!
Secondly, it is important to note that we are discussing 17 year old files from a much different version of ZBrush. All magnetic storage fails over time.
That said, if the files are .ZTL and they won’t open, there is nothing that can be done. Those files should be considered either corrupt or incompatible with the newer program version.
However, if they are .ZPR files you can try a couple different things.
Go to Preferences> Undo History and enable “Skip Loading” prior to trying to load the file. The issue could be related to an incompatible or problematic History if one is stored with the file.
Likewise you could try to use the Tool> Load Tools from project function. This will usually give you a good idea if the geometry is salvageable. If nothing comes in from that file the geometry is beyond recovery. If any subtools are replaced with primitive geometry, it would also let you know that there is nothing there to recover so you could at least move on.
Good luck!